Legal and Regulatory Framework for Refugee Employment in Turkey

Turkey has become a global focal point for refugee management, hosting around 3.57 million Syrian refugees under temporary protection. The country's approach has involved developing a comprehensive legal and regulatory framework aimed at facilitating the economic and social integration of refugees. This article delves into the legal provisions governing refugee employment in Turkey, the practical challenges faced, and recommendations for enhancing the framework.

Historical Context and Legal Foundations

The legal and regulatory framework for refugee employment in Turkey is built on several key pieces of legislation and regulations:

1. Law on Foreigners and International Protection (LFIP): Adopted in April 2013, this law establishes the general principles governing the status and rights of foreigners and international protection applicants in Turkey. It provides the legal basis for temporary protection, which includes the right to work.
2. Temporary Protection Regulation: Implemented in October 2014, this regulation specifically addresses the needs of Syrians fleeing the conflict. It grants them temporary protection status, ensuring access to essential services like health, education, and employment.
3. Regulation on Work Permits for Foreigners under Temporary Protection: Enacted in January 2016, this regulation outlines the process for Syrian refugees to obtain work permits, allowing them to participate in the formal labor market.

Key Provisions for Refugee Employment

The regulatory framework for refugee employment includes several critical components:

Work Permit Application Process:

• Refugees under temporary protection can apply for work permits six months after registration in Turkey.
• The application must be submitted by the employer through an online system managed by the Ministry of Family, Labor, and Social Services (MoFLSS).
• The application process has been simplified, with a reduced fee for Syrians (TRY 372.20) compared to other foreign workers (TRY 850.10).

Geographical and Sectoral Restrictions:

• Refugees must obtain work permits in the province where they are registered. Exceptions can be made for those who secure employment opportunities elsewhere, but this requires additional administrative steps.
• Some sectors, such as agriculture, are exempt from the work permit requirement, allowing refugees to engage in seasonal work without formal authorization.

Quota System:

• Employers are required to maintain a ratio of one Syrian worker to every ten Turkish employees. This quota aims to balance job opportunities between refugees and locals but can be adjusted based on sectoral needs.

Rights and Protections:

Refugees with work permits enjoy the same labor rights and protections as Turkish workers, including minimum wage, social security benefits, and workplace safety standards.

Implementation Challenges

• Despite the comprehensive framework, several challenges hinder the effective integration of Syrian refugees into the formal labor market:

Employer Reluctance:

• Many employers are hesitant to hire Syrian refugees due to perceived bureaucratic hurdles, cultural and language barriers, and the requirement to comply with minimum wage and social security contributions.
• Employers often prefer informal employment arrangements to avoid the costs associated with formal employment.

Informal Employment:

• A significant number of Syrian refugees work informally, often in low-paying and insecure jobs, lacking legal protections and social benefits. This perpetuates their vulnerability and hinders their long-term integration.

Provincial Restrictions:

• The requirement to work in the province of registration limits mobility and access to better job opportunities in other regions. While exceptions exist, the administrative process to obtain them can be cumbersome.
• 
  

Lack of Skills and Language Proficiency:

• Many Syrian refugees face difficulties in securing formal employment due to a lack of relevant skills and proficiency in the Turkish language. This limits their competitiveness in the job market and their ability to access higher-quality jobs.

Detailed Legal Procedures

Work Permit Application:

• Employers initiate the process by submitting a work permit application online through the MoFLSS system. The application requires documentation proving the refugee’s temporary protection status, the employer’s business registration, and the job offer details.
• Applications are reviewed, and permits are generally issued within a few weeks if all criteria are met. Permits are typically valid for one year but can be renewed.

Exemptions and Special Cases:

• Refugees working in agriculture are exempt from the work permit requirement, reflecting the sector’s high demand for labor and the informal nature of much agricultural work.
• For refugees seeking to work outside their province of registration, a request for relocation must be submitted and approved by the Directorate General of Migration Management (DGMM).

Enforcement and Compliance:

• Inspections are conducted to ensure compliance with labor laws and regulations. Employers found violating these rules can face penalties, although enforcement tends to focus on promoting compliance rather than punishment.

Social Security and Benefits:

• Refugees with work permits are enrolled in the social security system, granting them access to healthcare, unemployment insurance, and other social benefits.
• This formalization provides a safety net and contributes to their long-term socioeconomic stability.

Policy Recommendations

• To improve the effectiveness of the legal and regulatory framework for refugee employment, several policy recommendations can be considered:

Streamline Work Permit Procedures:

• Further simplify the work permit application process and reduce bureaucratic obstacles for employers. Consider offering additional support and incentives for companies willing to hire refugees.

Promote Informal to Formal Transition:

• Develop targeted programs to transition refugees from informal to formal employment. This could include awareness campaigns, vocational training, and financial incentives for businesses.

Expand Geographical Flexibility:

• Increase flexibility for refugees to work in provinces other than their place of registration, especially in regions with higher demand for labor. Simplifying the process for obtaining such exceptions would be beneficial.

Enhance Language and Skills Training:

• Invest in comprehensive language and vocational training programs tailored to the needs of refugees. Collaborate with the private sector to design training that aligns with labor market demands, improving employability.

Strengthen Social Cohesion Initiatives:

• Implement programs that foster social cohesion and address xenophobic attitudes. Encouraging interactions between refugees and host communities can reduce social tensions and improve integration.

Address Informal Employment:

• Develop strategies to formalize the informal labor market. This includes regularizing informal businesses and providing incentives for formal employment.

Support Refugee Entrepreneurship:

• Facilitate the establishment of businesses by refugees through access to microfinance, business development services, and easing bureaucratic hurdles. Encouraging entrepreneurship can create job opportunities for both refugees and locals.

Turkey’s legal and regulatory framework for refugee employment is a robust effort to integrate Syrian refugees into the labor market. While significant progress has been made, addressing implementation challenges and enhancing existing policies are crucial for maximizing the potential benefits of refugee inclusion. By refining the regulatory environment and fostering a supportive ecosystem for refugee employment, Turkey can continue to set an example of resilience and inclusivity in the face of one of the most significant refugee crises of our time.